Warning: Comic Book Geekery Ahead
I'm a fan of the Japanese manga style. Clean cut lines. Smooth curves. Perfect tone shading. Inventive use of foreshortening and perspective. Incredible consistency... But at some point it gets too formulaic.
When it comes to manga, most readers wouldn't be able to distinguish between a frame from Spirited Away and Steamboy. But if you ask that same person if Andy Capp and Bettle Bailey are drawn by the same artist it's an instant "NO!"
That's why I still look to Western comics. And I'm not talking about the popular Marvel "muscle-fest" style. I'm for Doonesbury, Bazooka Joe and The Far Side. I'm for Bill Watterson, Jamie Hewlitt, Genndy Tartakovsky, Sergio Aragones and Scott McCloud. The comics that breathe "style" in an industry that is slowly straying from its traditions.
 | But sometimes you get something that is a neither one nor the other. A little old, a little new (something borrowed, something blue). One of them is "SCOTT PILGRIM" by Bryan Lee O'Malley. It's a graphic novel series, now in its third volume, whose style is a marriage between American cartoon and Japanese manga.
This is just the type of thing I want to be doing. Deceptively simple, yet full of depth. A comic that isn't just a showcase of fancy poses and complex fight scenes. A comic that tells a good story.
Maybe someday. Hopefully soon. |
Oh, and the 3rd Scott Pilgrim book will also feature a 2-page guest comic done by one of my favourite comic artists,
Josh Lesnick. His works inlude
Wendy and
Girly, two of the craziest comics on the web. Lesnick isn't just an artist, he's a pop culture sensation!



all images hosted by Photobucket.com
*for those who'd like to know a little more about the references I made in my post, here's a list of the artists and their works.
| WORKS | ARTIST |
| Spirited Away | Hayao Miyazaki |
| Steamboy | Katsuhiro Otomo |
| Andy Capp | Reg Smythe |
| Beetle Bailey | Mort Walker |
| Doonesbury | GB Trudeau |
| Bazooka Joe | Wesley Morse |
| The Far Side | Gary Larson |
| Calvin and Hobbes | Bill Watterson |
| Tank Girl, Gorillaz | Jamie Hewlitt |
| Power Puff Girls, Samurai Jack | Genndy Tartakovsky |
| Groo, Mad Magazine | Sergio Aragones |
| Zot!, Morning Improv | Scott McCloud |
Scott Pilgrim image taken from http://scottpilgrim.com/
Otra, Winter and Marshmallo Cat images taken from http://go-girly.com